camp-soap-showdown-biodegradable-liquids-vs-leaves-vs-bars

CampDeck is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Choosing the right camp soap might seem like a minor detail, but when you’re miles from civilization, a little bit of effective cleaning goes a long way. And more importantly, you need to minimize your impact on the environment. This guide breaks down the pros and cons of the three main types of camp soap – biodegradable liquids, soap leaves, and bar soaps – to help you choose the best option for your next adventure. We’ll cover ease of use, cleaning power, environmental considerations, and any quirks we’ve noticed during our own trips.

Biodegradable Liquid Soap: The Versatile Option

Biodegradable liquid soap is a popular choice for camping because of its versatility. It can be used for washing dishes, clothes, your body, and even as a general cleaner.

Pros of Liquid Soap

• Multi-purpose: One bottle can handle almost all cleaning tasks.
• Easy to dispense: Controlled pouring means less waste.
• Good cleaning power: Effective at cutting grease and grime.

Cons of Liquid Soap

• Potential for leaks: Bottles can leak in your pack, especially at higher altitudes where pressure changes are more pronounced. Always double-bag it!
• Risk of overuse: It’s easy to pour out too much, leading to unnecessary waste and increased environmental impact. A small, clearly marked container (like a 2 oz travel bottle) can help.
• Can be sudsy: Some biodegradable soaps still produce suds, which are harmful to waterways. Look for truly “suds-free” formulas.

Liquid Soap Tips for Campers

• Choose a truly biodegradable option: Look for certifications like Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) or similar. Read the ingredients list carefully; avoid phosphates, dyes, and artificial fragrances.
• Use sparingly: A few drops are usually enough. Dilute the soap with water in a separate container before use.
• Dispose of wastewater properly: Carry water at least 200 feet (60 meters) away from any water source and dig a small hole (6-8 inches deep) to disperse the water. This allows the soil to filter the water.
• Consider a concentrated formula: These require less product per use, reducing the overall volume you need to carry.

Soap Leaves: The Ultralight Choice

Soap leaves are thin, dry sheets of soap that dissolve in water. They’re incredibly lightweight and compact, making them a favorite among backpackers and ultralight enthusiasts.

Pros of Soap Leaves

• Ultralight and compact: Takes up minimal space and weight in your pack.
• Pre-portioned: No risk of overuse or spills. Each leaf provides a measured amount of soap.
• Convenient: Easy to grab and use, even with wet hands.

Cons of Soap Leaves

• Can be flimsy: Easily torn or crumpled, especially in humid conditions. Keep them in a waterproof container.
• May not clean as effectively: Compared to liquid or bar soap, soap leaves might struggle with heavily soiled items.
• Limited versatility: Primarily designed for handwashing; less effective for dishes or laundry.

Soap Leaf Tips for Campers

• Keep them dry: Store soap leaves in a waterproof container to prevent them from dissolving prematurely. A small, resealable plastic bag inside a hard case works well.
• Use enough leaves: For larger cleaning tasks, you might need to use multiple leaves.
• Test before you go: Try the soap leaves at home to get a feel for how much water they need to dissolve and how effective they are at cleaning.
• Look for durable packaging: Some soap leaf dispensers are more robust than others. Opt for a sturdy case that won’t crush easily in your pack.

Bar Soap: The Classic Approach

Bar soap is a traditional cleaning option that’s still relevant for camping, especially for shorter trips where weight and space are less critical.

Pros of Bar Soap

• Effective cleaning: Generally provides good cleaning power for various tasks.
• Minimal packaging: Often comes with minimal or recyclable packaging.
• Long-lasting: A bar of soap can last for multiple trips, depending on usage.

Cons of Bar Soap

• Bulky and heavy: Takes up more space and adds more weight compared to liquid soap or soap leaves.
• Can get messy: Soap bars can become slimy and difficult to handle when wet.
• Requires a soap dish: To keep the bar clean and dry, you’ll need a soap dish or container.

Bar Soap Tips for Campers

• Choose a biodegradable option: Just like liquid soap, look for a truly biodegradable bar soap made with natural ingredients.
• Use a soap dish: A soap dish with drainage holes will help keep the bar dry and prevent it from becoming mushy.
• Cut the bar into smaller pieces: This reduces the overall weight and bulk, and prevents you from using more soap than necessary.
• Store it properly: Keep the bar soap in a waterproof container to prevent it from getting wet and dissolving in your pack.

Environmental Considerations for All Camp Soap

No matter which type of camp soap you choose, it’s crucial to minimize your environmental impact. Even biodegradable soaps can harm aquatic ecosystems if used improperly.

• Wash away from water sources: Always wash at least 200 feet (60 meters) away from any streams, lakes, or rivers.
• Dig a hole for wastewater: Dig a small hole (6-8 inches deep) to disperse wastewater. This allows the soil to filter the water before it reaches groundwater.
• Use sparingly: Less is more. Use only the amount of soap necessary to get the job done.
• Avoid direct application to water: Never wash directly in a water source.
• Pack out all trash: This includes any soap packaging, wrappers, or leftover soap bits.

Making the Right Choice for YOU

The best type of camp soap depends on your individual needs and preferences.

• For backpackers and ultralight enthusiasts: Soap leaves offer the best combination of weight, space, and convenience.
• For car campers and those prioritizing versatility: Biodegradable liquid soap is a solid choice, as long as you’re careful with dispensing and wastewater disposal.
• For shorter trips and those who prefer a traditional approach: Bar soap can be a good option, provided you’re willing to carry the extra weight and bulk.

Consider the length of your trip, the types of cleaning tasks you’ll need to perform, and your personal preferences when making your decision. No matter which option you choose, remember to use it responsibly and minimize your impact on the environment. Don’t forget to check our recommendations for the [best backpacks](backpacks setup checklist for beginners) to carry all your gear!